May 27, 2008
Fun Job!
There are very few people who know what exactly want to do with their future, career wise. The reason is that they do not realize what area interests them the most. Luckily, at least i know which is the area which appeals me the most.. and fortunately i have already got the job which i love. But this is only one of the reasons why i enjoy this job, a management faculty…. Being with students, having discussions and panel meetings on various current issues is something which is very fruitful and satisfying.
But the most hilarious and entertaining part of this job is to deal with various kinds and categories of students…. And the process starts right from the selection of students though GD PI and then continues even after the student appears for exam and the results come…
In recent days, i have been busy with almost every such activity in college. And believe me; i’ve experienced all such incidences which really makes me think : do some people really think??? Reason???? Read along….
Case 1 – GD PI process, i am on the panel for interview, and unfortunately, the candidates are selected after the final score of written and GD PI, we get variety of candidates. Excerpts from one of such interviews:
Me – you have written in your CV that you have done BCA. So why do you want to shift to management field? Don’t you want to continue in the same field and do MCA or MCM?
Candidate – no ma’am. I wish to have a management perspective and want to learn management.
My co - panelist– yes, that is what we are asking, why do you want to lean management?
Candidate – I want to know how to manage things.
Me – okay… and what do you mean by management then?
Candidate – management means ‘to manage’…
Co – panelist – ‘to manage’ what?
Candidate – Anything!
Co – panelist – anything?! Good.. (with sarcasm!!) Which specialization are you planning to take?
Candidate – HR
Me – Why? What do know about HR?
Candidate – HR is managing.
Co – panelist – (a little agitated) yes, but managing what?????
Candidate – managing people….. management!!
Me – what? We didn’t get you. What do mean by management?
Candidate – management means to manage.. Observe… doing managership!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Co – panelist – (now with lots of sarcasm!!) managership?!?! And What do you mean by that?
Candidate – means observing, doing management!!!
…..and then we realized we’ve just wasted 10 minutes asking this girl about something on which she is totally confused. So we decided just to award her some marks, let’s ask something about her own field. So..
co – panelist – okay, tell me what did you like in BCA?
Candidate – Computers! I liked Tally a lot. I also liked web-designing.
Me – oh good, you seem to know a lot about it then.
Candidate – yes ma’am, I know a lot about it.
Co – panelist – (now in a mood to have fun!!) okay then tell us who is the father of computers?
(We couldn’t believe she gave this answer!!!)
Candidate – I am sorry sir, my father is working WCL and he doesn’t know anything about computers..!!
……… and we thanked her from our heart for coming!!!
Case II – Same GD PI, another candidate….
Now this candidate was very good in his field, which was commerce, and knew answers to almost every technical question which we’d asked him. Apart from that, he had a dashing personality and had a good command over the language. Overall, we were almost satisfied with him, and decided to ask him a few HR cliché’ questions…
Me – Good..! What are your strengths and weakness?
Candidate – ma’am my strength is my communication skill (okay.. so far so good, we thought!) and my second strength is my body!
Co – panelist – (surprised!!) your what?
Candidate – my body sir. I am physically very strong and I can beat up anybody. And as my weakness is that I get angry very quickly, this strength of mine comes very handy!
Me – so you beat up people?
Candidate – yes ma’am, only when I am angry. But don’t worry ma’am, I never beat girls..!!!
… and my co – panelist (who was a male faculty) decided not have him on board!
Case III – This candidate had supposedly worked with some broking firm, had done BBA and was interested to take finance. Already agitated by the above two experiences, the moment i got this candidate, i thought chalo beta, aa gaye tuum hamare iilake me.. (me being a finance and economics faculty!)
Me – You have mentioned that you were a stock advisor with this firm, and did some research, tell me some of the non – stock market investment options.
Candidate – (with a fake accent) ma’am there are many options like real estate, gold, bonds, FDs etc etc etc…
Me – okay, what would you suggest if anybody want to invest for short term in a non – stock market options?
Candidate – I would recommend mutual funds.
Me – is it not related to stock market?
Candidate – no, not at all.
Me – okay, then where do these mutual fund companies invest money?
Candidate – ma’am they manage assets.
Me – yes, but which are these assets?
Candidate – assets are assets!
Me – (now really irritated) fine. ( I didn’t have to correct her, nor did I want to.) okay, tell me how many stock markets are there in India?
Candidate – 2.
Me – 2? (there are 24.) you sure?
Candidate – yes ma’am. BSE and NSE.
Me – yes, but there are few more.
Candidate – no ma’am. Not at all. Only 2. BSE, which is in Mumbai and NSE which is in Delhi.
Me – NSE is in Delhi?
Candidate- yes ma’am.
I was so frustrated at this point of time, that my co – panelist continued…
Co – panelist – who told this to you?
Candidate – nobody has to. I know.
… and with this answer, we didn’t waste any more time interviewing her….
Surprisingly, all these 3 candidates had very good scores in their written test. Whosoever made this compulsory to have GD PI after the written test was really a thinker. But, it made me wonder, how are they so bad when it comes to such an important process as interview? But yes, they do make my job a fun job!!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
29 comments:
These are really cool experiences. I know the candidates are generally very tense during interviews. But thats when best is supposed to come out. But then no worries till the experiences are funny..... Good one
I rally dont have a say in his coz i already have bombed 2 of those this year! But it was fun to read!
Hillarious experiences Ami :))
Hi, you enjoy being a faculty and doing the interviews ? i find it funny and interesting. lot of options in understanding mind of ppl and their weird / good thought processs...
Funny!
Why don't u write a book on the GD/PI experiences!
@ ands,
Yes, in fact sometimes they are so tensed that they just lose the control of what they are saying.. :D
@ ashish,
i know dear they were not as funny as these!
@ ashu,
Thanx buddy! :)
@ sam,
yes i do... i just love this job and these experiences make my day! :D
@ankur,
hm... good idea... to whom should i dedicate it to?
haha... :P
seriously... funny :P
and didnt know u r with some b-school???
may i know which one???
btw... i got through many of such interviews though i was a good scorer ;) :P :P
heheh
but i have seen ppl making mistakes... interviewing ppl in itself is a tough task!!!
and ppl say... how easy!!! :P
Cheers!!!
Cant believe this! :)
Hilarious!!
It was an interesting read.. :)gr8 tht u enjoy ur work thoroughly..
btw..even m from Finance n Economics field.. :)
Infact, recently completely a short assignment in Financial education..
Funny but sad too. Your experiences underline a fundamental fact about our social setup, particularly how we approach education. All three candidates might have scored high marks in their written tests but all three demonstrated the shallowness of their knowledge. The books say Mutual Funds are about asset management. The candidate never bothered to find out more. Whatever the book says is the gospel and to be repeated verbatim, without any effort to probe further.
Why? Why this sorry state of affairs? Are our teachers no good? Don't they teach our youngsters to look, really look around them? To question? To learn by themselves? Where is the drive, the hunger to understand and not just to make copies of copies?
The onus surely is on our teachers. For the child learns by observing.
- Gautam
What Ho!
Years back i was on the other side of the table..n dont tell me then people on the other side were actually enjoying jacking me:-p....interesting piece....I almost felt your restlessness with those "international answers" from candidates
thnx for sharing those...
@ ankur,
oh really? but then i am pretty sure you were far better than these people.. and fortunately, you'd already scored best :)
yes, interviewing people IS a real tough task!
@ rahul,
believe me, you really have to keep calm druing such experiences! :)
@ swati,
hey so good to hear that.. and if you don;t mind me asking, what was that assignment about? it would be an interesting read...
@ gautham,
yeah, even though i exhibited the funny side of the whole story, it surely says how much are we lacking in imparting practical education.
and as you said correctly, the onus is surely on our teachers, but still i feel there are still many things which these people can do by themself.. but unfortunately , many people still rely on spoon feeding, rather than catching the fish by themselves..
Thanx a lot for sharing your views! and welcome aboard!
@ sid,
naah, there are such international cases everywhere.. and we also get some of the very good candidates, and i am sure you must have been in the better lot! :)
but even you would ecperience it, that if a candidate is good enough, the interviewer also takes pleasure in interviewing such a candidate.. but when we get such people, then instead of fun, we get irritated! :(
oopsie!!reminds me of my own interview blunders!
he he he :)
kya kya "item" milte hain tujhe :)
keep posting abt more such incidents :)
@ gunj,
hehe... hope they were not as funny as these! (but i am sure they were not! :))
@ rahul,
i swear! i'll surely keep you people updating on more such stuff!
dont know abt better coz i was rejected for IIMs and XL and landed at Symbi!!!
have never understood the criteria that howcome academics plays a role???
if bookworms were the stars then there wud be no Dheerubhai in this world... i hate this education system where the studies are just based on theory and not knowledge!!!
ask my toppers and they will tell u who knows more!!!
huh!!
Cheers!!!
@ ankur,
yes you are very correct.. in fact, when i was doing my MBA, the toppers were the ones to get placed last.. which is very ironic..
haha... same here.. i have seen my toppers crying... wat else!!! :P
was among the first few to be placed d earliest tat too after leavin one offer!!! :D :D
and still was the most handsomely paid!!! :D
so toppers... huh... they suck anyways :P :P
some dont though ;)
Cheers!!!
@ ankur,
i guess this is the same scene across b-schools... :)
one of my colleague who sits in the cabin next to me asked why was i laughing. i jus showed him this post n he went away laughing.
buddy, this was great. the first girl was awesome. i would love to meet her.
the second one was even more talented. he doesn't beat girls!!!! no wonder y ur co-panel decided to leave him out.
btw, u r into teaching profession? that too in a management school?
@ satish,
:) :) thanx a lot for the appreciation.. if i anytime get her number, will sure pass it on to you...
yes, i am a lecturer in a management college.. :)
@radhika
i jus wrote that for fun... why do u want to make my life miserable by introducing her... :(
hey... did ya c Sarkar Raj or AAmir??
@ ankur,
yes, mai aur sarkar raj chodu!! naah...Sarkar rocks! :D
Post a Comment